Click on this link, http://www.ppro.frac.dk/portfolio-pro-critique.html to create your critique based on the following categories:
1. Technical
2. Composition
3. Impact
4. Commercial Viability
Rate each image on the above categories on a scale from 1 to 10. Write a paragraph about each category.
Paste each critique into the form on the bottom of the page inside of the html tags. Then give the image an overall score out of a possible 10 points. Then post a comment to the different critique page, by copying the html code you have made. Follow the example below.
Technical: 7
I think they contrast is good, but i just want more to look at.
Composition: 7
They look too basic. the rules are followed good, they still came out good.
Impact: 6
I dont think that they have a everlasting effect, but i think they are still pretty creative.
Commercial Viability: 5
I like the pictures something i could imagine, seeing blown up maybe.
Grade 6.25/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 8
I really like this picture. The colors are all very bright and sharp.
Composition: 5
The picture of the fence and the field looked pretty good, i dont think i would remember either picture on its own though.
Impact: 7
I LOVE how there is an over all theme to the pictures. it looks good.
Commercial Viability: 7
this could be in a baseball/softball magazine maybe.
Grade 6.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 8
both of these poot together totally make sence, because what’s a baseball game with out the plates, and what’s a baseball field withough a fence. and overall, i think they both look good together with the frame around them and everything.
Composition: 9
I love how part of the fence is out of focus. and how the plate gets darker on the way out. that gives a great effect.
Impact: 9
i think the impact is great, with the blur, and the composition. it makes it look more intersting, more bold.
Commercial Viability: 9
I could definatly see this picture going somewhere.
Grade 8.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 10
I absolutly love the coloring in this picture. It’s not to bright but not to dark either.
Composition: 9
I really think the balance is good too. Maybe not perfect but pretty close.
Impact: 9
I think it is really eye catching. Also it is really creative and I like it alot.
Commercial Viability: 7
Eh, i don’t think I would use it in a commercial but a magazine with a article about baseball it would be perfect, atleast i think so.
Grade 8.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 10
These ones are my favorite between the two sets. I think the color is perfect…they both pop very well. I love the sharpness too.
Composition: 8
I would say excellent or perhaps even perfect, but for some reason I dont like the way the base photo is placed in the picture.
Impact: 7
I will remember these cause they found a way to kind of burn into my mind. So thats a good sign :]
Commercial Viability: 10
For some reason I can see the chain link fence being used on the cover of some health info pamphlet you would find in a doctors office about “being healthy” haha.
Grade 8.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 8
I really like the base picture because the lighting is fantastic. It allows the base to be the focus of the photo. I also like the focus on the base so that you can really see the dirt on it.
Composition: 8
The person used the rule of thirds well. Due to the lighting, the color is well done on the base photo as well. I like the fence image I just think if the person had angled it a little more to the left it would have framed the field better. The gap in the fence picture makes me feel as if I fell through it when I look at the photo. The color is pretty good in it though.
Impact: 9
I definitely think I’ll remember the base photo. It’s so pleasing to the eye because of it’s lighting and position in the photo. I don’t think I’ll remember the fence photo as well though.
Commercial Viability: 9
The base photo could definitely be used for baseball or the “get out and play” organization. I think it would definitely look good to promote playing outside and baseball.
Grade 8.5/10
Technical: 10
The color was just right and not one part of the picture took away from another part.
Composition: 9
I like how the baseball diamond is really standing out and towards the dirt it starts to get darker as you look out more.
Impact: 10
This is a picture that would catch my eye if I was just to walk by an art gallery or something.
Commercial Viability: 10
I would definatley think this could be a picture on a poster for a baseball brochure or advertisment.
Grade 9.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 7
very well and put togeth image. (:
Composition: 7
The colors in the photo on the left are beautiful, but with the photo on the right, the composition is very bland.
Impact: 7
the one on the left i will remember, i guess, just because the photo is just very contrasted and pretty. The one on the right is very plain.
Commercial Viability: 6
I’m not really sure what it could be used for, but im sure it could be used for something. (:
Grade 6.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 8
I liked the color balance in the photos and the sharpness.
Composition: 8
The depth of field looked really good.
Impact: 7
I think this would be a photo that might be remembered.
Commercial Viability: 8
This was pretty good overall.
Grade 7.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 8
I like the color in this photo because its not too dark or too bright.
Composition: 8
The two photos show good depth of field.
Impact: 9
I will remember this picture because i like the out doors and like playing the spot of baseball.
Commercial Viability: 6
I like the fine arts of the fience and the base.
Grade 7.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)