Click on this link to create your critique based on the following categories:
1. Technical
2. Composition
3. Impact
4. Commercial Viability
Rate each image on the above categories on a scale from 1 to 10. Write a paragraph about each category.
Paste each critique into the form on the bottom of the page inside of the html tags. Then give the image an overall score out of a possible 1o points. Then post your critique as a comment to this page, by copying the html code you have made. Follow the example below.
Technical: 7
It’s over all a nice photo, i think there could be more added to it. But how it’s darker in some places and lighter in others gives the picture a more interesting look. So i like that.
Composition: 8
I like the compsition, how it gets more blurry on the way out, and how the colors start different on the ends but equal out in the middle.
Impact: 8
There’s a good impact to this picture. I like how it’s not just the hand that you see, it’s all the lines in the hand too.
Commercial Viability: 8
I could see this somewhere advertising some kind of a sickness, as a photo for that. I think it would look great, because that’s what the photo reminds me of.
Grade 7.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Its a hand. I don’t like it.
Technical: 4
ehh. i dont really have an opinion. i don’t like this mich. my mind is drawing a blank..
Composition: 5
its a hand
Impact: 3
this is a photo that i will probably have already forgotten in a few minutes.
Commercial Viability: 6
Maybe a comercial for a hand cream or lotion?
Grade 4.5/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
Technical: 7
I really like the balance between the blacks, grays, and whites.
Composition: 6
It was taken in a artistic way. I like how the hand looks aged
Impact: 7
I think that I will remember this photo. I really like it.
Commercial Viability: 7
It would be used as many different things
Grade 6.75/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
1. Technical: 7 I really like how the hand looks old and dirty.
2. Composition: 6 I think the picture would have been better taken from far away.
3. Impact: 5 It doesnt really impact me, I think if it was farther away it would have made a difference.
4. Commercial Viability: 6 It could be good for a hand soap commercial. One that makes your hands clean, and soft too!
Technical: 5
I think it has good texture and the color matches the ageing of the hand, it also is very sharp.
Composition: 4
It’s an intence photo but it doesnt really have much depth.
its clear but. eh.
Impact: 6
I think it hits your hard with the age and all but i dont find it to be that great of a photo, its good but in a weird way.
Commercial Viability: 3
all i could see this is is in a lotion comerical.
Grade 4.5/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)
1. Technical: I think it has Good Texture, its nice because the color or tone of the photo match the aging of the mans hand.
2. Composition: I think its pretty intence.
3. Impact: I think its pretty good, but not to much of an impact.
4. Commercial Viability: It could be for a hand lotion comerical.
i like this picture a lot. i like the way it looks and the color. i would say the inpact is strong. you can see every line in the hand. you can tell its a working mans hand because of the dirt in the line of the hand. for technical i would rate it a 8.5 and for composition i would rate it a 8 and for impact i would rate it a 9.5 and for commercial viability i would say a 8.
Technical: 8
i like the color of the things that they did. i like the dark areas where it shows where the light can’t get.
Composition: 7
I like the color of it it’s not really black and white, it’s like it has some brown.
Impact: 7
i thought it was an a okay picture but it didn’t really catch me eye. But it did seem that the person lives outside because his skin seems dirtish.
Commercial Viability: 7
it can show people what kind of skins people had in those days.
Grade 7.25/10 as seen in
(generated by the G&C helper)